Court Judgments 2023

Once a matter has been completed, a judgment or decision is given. After a judgment is given in Court, it is available online.

The following are the most recent judgments made in the Courts.  Use our search tool to find previous judgments from the Courts.

Court of Appeal Judgments

December

• File

  Rex v AH and AW [2023] COA (Bda) 29 Cri. (21 December 2023) (348.72 KB)
• File

  Bermuda Press (Holdings) Limited v Evatt Tamine [2023] CA (Bda) 28 Civ, 13 December 2023 (3.25 MB)
• File

  Credit Suisse Life (Bermuda) Limited v Ivanishvili - Ruling on costs 8 Dec 2023 (260.23 KB)

November

• File

  Taaj Muhammad v The King [2023] CA (Bda) 21 Crim, 17 November 2023 (369.43 KB)
• File

  Anthony Davis v The King [2023] CA (Bda) 22 Crim, 17 November 2023 (207.07 KB)
• File

  Raynor, Belboda, Outerbridge, Smith and Robinson v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board [2023] CA (Bda) 23 Civ, 17 November 2023 (329.88 KB)
• File

  Raymond Charlton v The King [2023] CA (Bda) 24 Crim, 17 November 2023 (247.41 KB)
• File

  Shae Butterfield v The King [2023] CA (Bda) 25 Crim, 17 November 2023 (248.19 KB)
• File

  Stevedoring Services Limited v Minister of Labour & Economy et el [2023] CA (Bda) 26 Civ, 17 November 2023 (460.27 KB)

October

• File

  Templar Capital Limited v Griffin Line General Trading LLC & Ors [2023] CA (Bda) 20 Civ, 23 October 2023.pdf (221.74 KB)

July

• File

  Wolda Gardner v The Director of Public Prosecutions and The Attorney General [2023] CA (Bda) 19 Civ, 21 July 2023 (186.87 KB)
• File

  Wong, Wen-Young v Grand View Private Trust Company Limited et al [2023] CA (Bda) 18 Civ 21 July 2023 (222.44 KB)
• File

  Cheyra Bell v Attorney-General & Ors [2023] CA (Bda) 17 Civ, 7 July 2023 (252 KB)

June

• File

  CS Life (Bermuda) Ltd. v Ivanishvili et al [2023] CA (Bda) 13 Civ, 23 June 2023 (774.96 KB)
• File

  Wanda Pedro v The Attorney-General [2023] CA (Bda) 14 Civ, 23 June 2023 (330.53 KB)
• File

  Terrence Walker v Rex [2023] CA (Bda) 16 Crim, 23 June 2023 (467.79 KB)
• File

  Global Distressed v Herman and Eddlestone [2023] CA (Bda) 12 Civ, 23 June 2023 (363.08 KB)
• File

  Tyshaun Brown v Rex [2023] CA (Bda) 15 Crim, 23 June 2023 (297.76 KB)
• File

  The Information Commissioner v The Attorney-General (Costs Ruling) [2023] CA (Bda) 11 Civ, 7th June 2023 (229.45 KB)

May

• File

  Durham and Durham v Rex [2023] CA (Bda) 10 Civ, 15 May 2023 (301.26 KB)
• File

  TT v VE [2023] CA (Bda) 9 Civ, 15 May 2023 (301.53 KB)

March

• File

  Dave Anderson Greenidge v The Commissioner of Police [2023] CA (Bda) 8 Civ, 23 March 2023 (306 KB)
• File

  In the Matter of Jardine Strategic Holdings Ltd. [2023] CA (Bda) 7 Civ, 24 March 2023 (371.32 KB)
• File

  Information Commissioner v The Attorney-General [2023] CA (Bda) 6 Civ, 24 March 2023 (423.44 KB)
• File

  Titan Petrochemicals Group Ltd v Sino Charm International & Ors (Costs) [2023] CA (Bda) 5 Civ, 2 March 2023 (392.16 KB)

February

• File

  In the Matter of the "X Trust" [2023] CA (Bda) 4 Civ, 17 February 2023 (1.36 MB)
• File

  Cheyra Bell v The Attorney-General et al [2023] CA (Bda) 3 Civ, 17 February 2023 (306.8 KB)
• File

  A Minor (by their next of kin) v The Minister of Education [2023] CA (Bda) 2 Civ, 17 February 2023 (200.63 KB)

January

• File

  Corporation of Hamilton v The Attorney General & Anor [2023] CA (Bda) 1 Civ (428.19 KB)

Supreme Court Judgments

December

• File

  AB v Mount Saint Agnes Academy [2021] SC (Bda) 94 Civ. (1 December 2023) (560.13 KB)
• File

  Muhammad Ziaullah Khan Chishti v Afiniti Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 98 Civ. (19 December 2023) (773.39 KB)
• File

  N. E. v W. E. [2023] SC (Bda) 96 Div. (8 December 2023) (664.01 KB)
• File

  Amir Mizrachy v The King [2021] SC (Bda) 81 App (6 December 2023) (430.76 KB)
• File

  Amir Mizrachy v The King [2023] SC (Bda) 80 App (6 December 2023) (337.28 KB)

November

• File

  The King v Raheem Wray [2022] SC (Bda) 97 Cri. (20 November 2023) (622.84 KB)
• File

  The King v John Seaman [2019] SC (Bda) 95 Cri. (30 November 2023) (522.71 KB)
• File

  Jennifer Wade v Tanika Williams et al [2022] SC (Bda) 93 Civ. (29 November 2023) (504.42 KB)
• File

  Lauretta Stoneham v Bertram Fraser [2020] SC (Bda) 92 Civ. (29 November 2023) (871.85 KB)
• File

  Gloyd Robinson v The Bermuda Civil Aviation Authority & The Minister of Transport [2022] SC (Bda) 91 Civ. (22 November 2023) (344.84 KB)
• File

  KPMG Tax Limited v Frank Majors et al [2021] SC (Bda) 90 Civ. (22 November 2023) (268.87 KB)
• File

  HSBC Bank Bermuda Limited v Sanz Pearman [2019] SC (Bda) 89 Civ. (22 November 2023) (392.82 KB)
• File

  My Pharmacy LLC v The Minister of Health et al [2023] SC (Bda) 88 Civ. (22 November 2023) (401.99 KB)
• File

  Marcus Uddin v The Commissioner of Police [2023] SC (Bda) 84 Civ. (6 November 2023) (934.73 KB)

October

• File

  James Watlington v Shawn Thomas [2023] SC (Bda) 85 Civ (25 October 2023).pdf (531.18 KB)
  File

  Brian Alkon v The Queen [2023] SC (Bda) 82 App (23 October 2023) (478.66 KB)
• File

  Sheila Thomas v Haile Maskal (Trading as WEST SIDE CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT) [2023] SC (Bda) 83 Civ. (20 October 2023).pdf (1.88 MB)
• File

  KPMG Tax Limited v Frank Majors et al [2023] SC (Bda) 78 Civ. (20 October 2023).pdf (807.69 KB)
• File

  Trump Panama et al v Hotel Toc Inc. et al [2023] SC (Bda) 74 Civ. (12 October 2023) (945.5 KB)
• File

  Rita Furbert v Willison Furbert & Dawn Furbert [2023] SC (Bda) 76 Civ. (10 October 2023) (730.07 KB)
• File

  AML Creditor Recovery Vehicle (PTC) v (1) Madison Pacific Trust Limited et al [2023] SC (Bda) 77 Civ. (9 October 2023) (552.25 KB)
• File

  Athene Holding Limited v Imran Siddiqui et al [2023] SC (Bda) 75 Civ. (9 October 2023) (775.52 KB)
• File

  Gloyd Robinson v The Bermuda Civil Aviation Authority & The Minister of Transport [2023] SC (Bda) 73 Civ. (6 October 2023) (751.18 KB)
• File

  Zahra Harper v The Commissioner of the Bermuda Police Service [2023] SC (Bda) 72 Civ. (6 October 2023) (765.73 KB)

September 

• File

  The King v Davin Kyron Thomas Dill [2021] SC (Bda) 87 Cri. (8 September 2023) (452.49 KB)
• File

  The King v Josiah Quinton King [2023] SC (Bda) 79 Cri. (29 September 2023) (494.75 KB)
• File

  John Zuill and Rebecca Brady [2023] SC (Bda) 71 Civ. (13 September 2023) (442.11 KB)
• File

  R v Christian Sousa Matias [2023] SC (Bda.) 70 Cri. (11 September 2023) (232.27 KB)
• File

  Beverly Griffith and Bermuda High School for Girls [2023] SC (Bda) 69 Civ. (8 September 2023) (240.55 KB)

August

• File

  The King v Davin Kyron Thomas Dill [2021] SC (Bda) 86 Cri. (21 August 2023) (593.98 KB)
• File

  In the Matter of Island Ophthalmology Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 68 Civ. (22 August 2023) (561.47 KB)
• File

  APS Holding Corporation & Alpine Partners (BVI) v Myovant Sciences Ltd [2023] SC (Bda) 67 Civ. (25 August 2023) (726.97 KB)
• File

  AML Creditor Recovery Vehicle (PTC) v (1) Madison Pacific Trust Limited (2) Shandong Iron & Steel Group Co. Limited (3) Shandong SteelInternational Investment Limited (4) Shandong Steel Hong Kong Resources Limited (5) Shandong Steel Hong Kong Zengli Limit (947.91 KB)
• File

  Terry Lynn Thompson v (1) The Public Service Union (2) His Excellency The Governor of Bermuda & (3) The Attorney General [2023] SC (Bda) 65 Civ. (8 August 2023) (445.71 KB)
• File

  St. John's Trust Company (PVT) Limited v (1) James Watlington (2) Glenn Ferguson (3)Cabarita (PTA) Limited (4) The Attorney General (5) James Gilbert [2023] SC (Bda) 63 Civ. (2 August 2023) (492.21 KB)
• File

  Geoffrey Randall Willcocks v (1) Joseph E. Wakefield & (2) Wakefield Quin Limited [2023] SC (Bda) 62 Civ. (11 August 2023) (794.83 KB)
• File

  Mailboxes Unlimited Limited v Minister for the Cabinet Office [2023] SC (Bda) 61 Civ. (1 August 2023) (672.18 KB)

July

• File

  Brightside Enterprises Limited v Ruby J Lightbourne-Lamb and G Lightbourne v R J L-L et al [2023] SC (Bda) 64. (31 July 2023) (664.87 KB)
• File

  In the Matter of CICA Life Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 60 Civ. (27 July 2023) (270.86 KB)
• File

  The Queen v Cahlii Smith [2023] SC (Bda) 59 Cri. (17 July 2023) (4.78 MB)
• File

  In the Matter of Omnia Limited [2023] SC (Bda) 58 Civ. (28 July 2023) (306.84 KB)
• File

  In the Matter of Northstar Financial Services (Bermuda) Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 57 Civ. (28 July 2023) (718.41 KB)
• File

  Hillcrest Properties Ltd v Ian McDonald Smith [2023] SC (Bda) 56 Civ. (6 July 2023) (438.74 KB)
• File

  Paul and Theresa Rodrigues v Clearwater Development Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 55 Civ. (11 July 2023) (633.49 KB)
• File

  Paul and Theresa Rodrigues v Clearwater Development Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 54 Civ. (5 July 2023) (601.24 KB)

June

• File

  R v O [2023] SC (Bda) 52 Div. (15 June 2023) (632.61 KB)
• File

  The King v Nancy Viera [2023] SC (Bda) 53 Cri. (9 May 2023) (9.43 MB)
• File

  Jeffrey Lincohn MacLeod v BMSG Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 51 Civ. (15 June 2023) (725.47 KB)
• File

  Mexico Infrastructure Finance LLC v COH and Bank NY Mellon [2023] SC (Bda) 50 Com. (7 June 2023) (529.95 KB)

May

• File

  Leyoni Junos v The Premier of Bermuda E. David G. Burt et al [2023] SC (Bda) 49 Civ. (31 May 2023) (295.03 KB)
• File

  Robert Moulder v Commission of Inquiry into the Historic Losses of Land in Bermuda [2023] SC (Bda) 48 Civ. (31 May 2023) (1.18 MB)
• File

  Commission of Historic Loss of Land in Bermuda vs Leyoni Junos et al [2023] SC (Bda) 47 Civ. (31 May 2023) (185.98 KB)
• File

  Steve M. Franks v Troy Burgess [2023] SC (Bda) 46 Civ. (24 May 2023) (1.15 MB)
• File

  Mexico Infrastructure Finance LLC v Wakefield Quin Limited & Johann Oosthuizen [2023] SC (Bda) 45 Com. (22 May 2023) (4.28 MB)

April

• File

  In the Matter of the Z Trusts, A, B and Another v D and Others [2023] SC (Bda) 44 Civ. (28 April 2023) (5.03 MB)
• File

  V v V [2023] SC (Bda) 43 Div. (14 April 2023) (308.3 KB)
• File

  Fiona Miller (Police Sergeant/Informant) v Taahir Augustus [2023] SC (Bda) 42 App. (20 April 2023) (3.37 MB)
• File

  HSBC Bank of Bermuda Limited v John Percival White [2023] SC (Bda) 41 Civ. (24 April 2023) (643.18 KB)
• File

  R v O [2023] SC (Bda) 40 Div. (21 April 2023) (345.53 KB)
• File

  Leyoni Junos v The Governor of Bermuda [2023] SC (Bda) 39 Cri. (21 April2023) (2.63 MB)
• File

  Mid-Atlantic Wellness Institute Administration for Donna Williams [2023] SC (Bda) 38 Cri. (20 April 2023) (1.53 MB)
• File

  In the Matter of Jardine Strategic Holdings Limited [2023] SC (Bda) 37 Civ. (21 April 2023) (768.99 KB)
• File

  HSBC Bank of Bermuda Limited v Ambiance Holdings Ltd. & Carlton Simmons [2023] SC (Bda) 36 Cri. (20 April 2023) (6.3 MB)
• File

  R v ABC [2023] SC (Bda) 34 Cri. (17 April2023) (4.04 MB)
• File

  The King v Winston Paynter [2023] SC (Bda) 33 Cri. (12 April 2023) (5.72 MB)
• File

  Tatung Company v Chungwha Picture Tubes Limited et. al [2023] SC (Bda) 32 (21 April 2023) (756.99 KB)
• File

  In the Matter of P Trusts [2023] SC (Bda) 31 Civ. (20 April 2023) (539.73 KB)
• File

  The King v Maleke Martin [2023] SC (Bda) 30 Civ. (11 April 2023) (3.5 MB)
• File

  The Queen v Makhail Saltus & Giovanni Saltus [2023] SC (Bda) 29 Cri. (5 April2023) (3.23 MB)
• File

  Khamisi Tokunbo v The Commissioner of Police and The Attorney General and PC Colin Mill [2023] SC (Bda) 23 Civ. (20 April 2023) (291.57 KB)

March

• File

  Bermuda Healthcare Services Ltd. and Brown Darrell Clinic v Tuviere Ideh [2023] SC (Bda) 34 Civ. (31 March 2023) (511.18 KB)
• File

  Marshalle Augustus v The Estate of Wendell Gibbons [2023] SC (Bda) 28 Cri (31 March 2023) (5.09 MB)
• File

  AB v Mount Saint Agnes Academy [2023] SC (Bda) 27 Civ. (30 March 2023) (3.44 MB)
• File

  R v Anthony Davis Sentence [2023] SC (Bda) 26 Cri (29 March 2023) (2.08 MB)
• File

  Mexico Infrastructure Finance LLC v The Corporation of Hamilton & Mexico Infrastructure Finance LLC v Terra Law Limited [2023] SC (Bda) 25 Com (27 March 2023) (10.85 MB)
• File

  Griffin Line General Trading LLC v (1) Centaur Ventures Ltd and (2) Templar Capital Ltd [2023] SC (Bda) 24 Civ. (31 March 2023) (1.17 MB)
• File

  Ranae Patrice Cann v (1) Muhsin Nasir and (2) Bermuda Elite Athletic Strength Training Limited [2023] SC (Bda) 21 Civ. (24 March 2023) (869.38 KB)
• File

  Marcus Uddin v The Commissioner of Police [2023] SC (Bda) 20 Civ. (23 March 2023) (640.37 KB)
• File

  Leyoni Junos v The Governor of Bermuda [2023] SC (Bda) 19 Civ. (10 March 2023) (916.75 KB)
• File

  Robert G. G. Moulder v Commission of Inquiry [2023] SC (Bda) 18 Civ (8 March 2023) (337.95 KB)
• File

  In the Matter of the Island Ophthalmology Ltd. [2022] SC (Bda) 337 Civ. (20 February 2023) (1.26 MB)

February

• File

  The Queen v Terrance Walker [2023] SC (Bda) 15 Civ. (27 February 2023) (9.94 MB)
• File

  US Holdings Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 13 Civ. (17 February 2023) (5.48 MB)
• File

  Doleta Bean v Anthony Caisey and Keith Caisey [2023] SC (Bda) 12 Civ. (22 February 2023) (2.27 MB)
• File

  J.L.B. v P.E.B. [2023] SC (Bda) 9 Civ. (15 February 2023) (1.61 MB)
• File

  ​​​​​​​Oasis Investment II Master Fund Limited and Others v (1) Jardine Strategic Holdings Limited and (2) Jardine Strategic Limited [2023] SC (Bda) 8 Civ. (14 February 2023) (4.32 MB)

January

• File

  The Queen v AB & CD [2023] SC (Bda) 10 Cri. (30 January 2023) (10.42 MB)
• File

  The Queen v David Curley [2023] SC (Bda) 7 Cri. (25 January 2023) (9.28 MB)
• File

  Dwyer Williams et al v Erica Williams [2023] SC (Bda) 6 Civ. (26 January 2023) (272.57 KB)
• File

  Wanda Booth et al v HSBC Bank Bermuda Limited et al [2023] SC (Bda) 5 Civ. (26 January 2023) (3.75 MB)
• File

  Dove & Butterfly v The Director of Social Insurance & The Minister of Finance [2023] SC (Bda) 4 Civ. (12 January 2023) (3.72 MB)
• File

  F v MFP and FFP and Director of Child & Family Services SC (Bda) 3 Civ. (13 January 2023) (2.49 MB)
• File

  Lone Star v Hugh Ward III [2023] SC (Bda) 2 Civ. (12 January 2023) (698.23 KB)
• File

  PB Life and Annuity Co. Ltd. [2023] SC (Bda) 1 (12 January 2023) (1009.24 KB)